• Jump to main content
  • Jump to main navigation
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Media Centre
  • Contact
  • The Brain
Hymans Robertson
  • Pensions
    • Back to Main Menu
    • Defined Benefit Consulting
      • DB Actuarial
      • DB Investment
      • DB Pensions Administration
      • DB Risk Transfer
      • DB Member Choice – At retirement
      • DB Governance
      • DB Consolidation
      • DB Wind-up
      • DB Endgame Strategy
      • Expert Actuarial Services
      • Fiduciary Oversight
      • Climate Change Services
      • Responsible Investment
      • Project Planning and Management
    • Defined Contribution Consulting
      • DC Pension Strategy
      • DC Scheme Structure
      • DC Investment
      • DC Engagement
      • DC Member Choice - At-retirement
      • DC Governance
      • Guided Outcomes
      • DC Master Trusts
      • Benefits and Rewards Strategy
      • Project Planning and Management
      • Climate Change Services
      • Responsible Investment
      • Communications
    • Public Sector Consulting
      • LGPS Actuarial
      • LGPS Investment
      • LGPS Governance, Administration and Projects
      • LGPS Employers
      • LGPS Online Learning Academy
      • Ill Health Liability Insurance
      • Climate Change Services
      • Responsible Investment
  • Financial Services
    • Back to Main Menu
    • Insurance
      • Longevity Management
      • Product Development
      • Risk and Capital Management
      • Investment and ALM
      • Property and Casualty
      • Regulated Roles
      • Insurance Transactions
      • Project Planning and Management
    • HRIS
      • Tailored Portfolio Service
    • Pension Providers
      • Digital Tools and APIs
      • Competitive Benchmarking
      • Proposition development
      • Operational Support
    • Digital Wealth
      • GO™ For Investment Pathways
      • Economic Scenario Service
      • API Catalogue
      • Strategic Asset Allocation
  • Digital & Innovation
    • Back to Main Menu
    • Digital & Innovation
      • API Catalogue
      • Economic Scenario Service
      • Digital Products
      • PRISM - Digital Pension Administration
    • Economic Scenario Service
      Explore the consequences of today's business decisions
    • Digital and Innovation
      We apply data science, technology expertise and innovation to help our clients build a better financial future.
  • Insights
    • Back to Main Menu
    • See all Insights
      • Webinars
      • Podcasts
      • Research and Publications
      • Blogs
      • Case studies
      • Press Releases
      • Events
    • Webinars
      Register for upcoming webinars as well as visiting our extensive webinar replay library.
    • All Insights
      See our latest thinking.
  • Team
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Media Centre
  • Contact
  • The Brain
  • Search

Our website uses cookies (what’s this?). These cookies allow us to distinguish you from other users of our website, which helps us improve our website and to deliver many of the functions that make your browser experience more user-friendly. Some of the cookies that we use are essential for parts of the website to operate. By using this website you agree to our use of cookies. To find out more, including how to opt out, please read our Cookies Policy.

OK

Blog

Is CDC going to gain momentum?

05 Apr 2022

Kathryn Fleming

by Kathryn Fleming
Partner

Subject: Retirement solutions, Workplace savings & DC pensions

Audiences: Employers, Trustees

The recent announcement from the Department of Work and Pensions (DWP), combined with the recent Pensions Regulator (TPR) consultation, has provided a real flavour for the expectations that will be set for Collective Defined Contribution pensions schemes (CDC). A CDC scheme is a new type of pension scheme into which employees and employers both pay a fixed rate of contributions. The contributions are invested in pooled assets. Members are paid an income from these pooled assets which will have variable increases i.e. their income can, on occasion, remain flat or even potentially decrease. From an employers’ perspective, they are attractive as there's no deficit contribution to be paid, as in a Defined Benefit (DB) pension schemes. From an employees' perspective, there will be no requirement to make complicated investment decisions like with Defined Contribution (DC) pension schemes; and although there is no promised benefit (like in DB) an employee is provided with an indicative income amount, which really helps with engagement and retirement planning. 

This all sounds positive, but there are still notable discussions underway on how likely it is that CDC will be utilised as a preferred scheme design for employers. Our analysis indicates that despite the fact that a compelling case can be made for CDC, there are still a number of areas of concern. Our analysis shows that for an established stable scheme, CDC can lead to better outcomes by increasing incomes, versus current DC options, such as a Trust or Master Trust for accumulation, combined with the various approaches to exercising the pensions freedoms, from drawdown, enhanced annuity purchase to optimal approaches of decumulation design. However, the complex task of scheme design is all-important and different designs can make the benefits of CDC less clear-cut for some members. Furthermore, achieving good member outcomes during the early years of establishing a scheme is likely to be more challenging than for an established scheme in a steady state.  

We also can’t overlook the level of investment needed to set up the scheme, the costs associated with meeting TPR’s ongoing expectations as set out in the draft code of practice and the ability to succeed is inextricably linked to time and maintaining a large, stable population of savers. Our analysis also suggests that the audience of employers that CDC schemes will realistically appeal to will be narrow.

What about CDC for decumulation only, could that be an option, for example, if it was introduced into a Master Trust?

When looking at decumulation, there is certainly scope for CDC to add value and improve outcomes by increasing incomes. When we consider the reasons why decumulation doesn’t work well for savers in the current workplace pension arena; this includes the places where they lose money, costs of exiting accumulation and entering decumulation, mismatched investment strategies, poor education leading to poor choices, lack of understanding of longevity, currently small pot sizes, and so on. If introduced with a strong communications wrapper, the ability to pool longevity and investments to deliver more income has strong appeal, perhaps as an at-retirement option. 

For this to be attractive to a Master Trust or pension provider, it feels like there are a few challenges to overcome. Firstly, CDC in decumulation would be another option presented to retirees when they are already overwhelmed with the range of different options and are struggling to make decisions. This might point towards a prioritisation of communication and digital engagement strategies for pension providers before introducing another complexity. The wrestle between guidance and advice, and perhaps finding the sweet spot of tailored guidance in the middle could be considered a priority area. If retirees are more informed when exercising their choices, you could see how CDC in decumulation could make a better business case on providers development priorities. 

Any at-retirement option should be delivered with careful two-way engagement and flexibility, managing changes to the health, wealth and family circumstances to those in retirement. The pension providers live to this challenge, and this feels, appropriately, like the current priority area of focus for the short to medium term.

If you would like to discuss anything covered in this blog, please get in touch.

Subscribe to our news and insights

Related content

Current Issues - July 2022

Publications 01 Jul 2022

The Future of Retirement Savings Conference

Events 03 Nov 2022, London

Responsible Investment News and Views – June 2022

Publications 06 Jun 2022

Current Issues - June 2022

Publications 01 Jun 2022

0 comments on this post

Comment

  • Share this via Twitter
  • Share this via Linkedin
  • Share this via Email
Related content
Close related articles

Current Issues - July 2022

Publications

The Future of Retirement Savings Conference

Events 03 Nov 2022, London

Responsible Investment News and Views – June 2022

Publications

Current Issues - June 2022

Publications

Subscribe to our news and insights

Menu

About

    • Abelica Global
    • About us
    • Award-winning advice
    • Careers
    • CSR
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Our Centenary

Legal

  • Accessibility
  • Modern Slavery Act Transparency Statement
  • Trust centre
  • Privacy notice
  • Terms of use

Resources

  • Conflicts of Interest
  • Coronavirus (COVID-19)
  • Responsible Investment
  • Gender Pay Gap
  • Sitemap

Contact

  • Our offices
  • Get in touch
  • Subscribe
    • Visit us on Linkedin
    • Visit us on Twitter
    • Visit us on Instagram
    • Visit us on Vimeo
    • Visit us on Spreaker
Hymans Robertson

Copyright © 2022 Hymans Robertson LLP. All rights reserved.