• Jump to main content
  • Jump to main navigation
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Media Centre
  • Contact
  • The Brain
Hymans Robertson
  • Pensions
    • Back to Main Menu
    • Defined Benefit Consulting
      • DB Actuarial
      • DB Investment
      • DB Pensions Administration
      • DB Risk Transfer
      • DB Member Choice – At retirement
      • DB Governance
      • DB Consolidation
      • DB Wind-up
      • DB Endgame Strategy
      • Expert Actuarial Services
      • Fiduciary Oversight
      • Climate Change Services
      • Responsible Investment
      • Project Planning and Management
    • Defined Contribution Consulting
      • DC Pension Strategy
      • DC Scheme Structure
      • DC Investment
      • DC Engagement
      • DC Member Choice - At-retirement
      • DC Governance
      • Guided Outcomes
      • DC Master Trusts
      • Benefits and Rewards Strategy
      • Project Planning and Management
      • Climate Change Services
      • Responsible Investment
      • Communications
    • Public Sector Consulting
      • LGPS Actuarial
      • LGPS Investment
      • LGPS Governance, Administration and Projects
      • LGPS Employers
      • LGPS Online Learning Academy
      • Ill Health Liability Insurance
      • Climate Change Services
      • Responsible Investment
  • Financial Services
    • Back to Main Menu
    • Insurance
      • Longevity Management
      • Product Development
      • Risk and Capital Management
      • Investment and ALM
      • Property and Casualty
      • Regulated Roles
      • Insurance Transactions
      • Project Planning and Management
    • HRIS
      • Tailored Portfolio Service
    • Pension Providers
      • Digital Tools and APIs
      • Competitive Benchmarking
      • Proposition development
      • Operational Support
    • Digital Wealth
      • GO™ For Investment Pathways
      • Economic Scenario Service
      • API Catalogue
      • Strategic Asset Allocation
  • Digital & Innovation
    • Back to Main Menu
    • Digital & Innovation
      • API Catalogue
      • Economic Scenario Service
      • Digital Products
      • PRISM - Digital Pension Administration
    • Economic Scenario Service
      Explore the consequences of today's business decisions
    • Digital and Innovation
      We apply data science, technology expertise and innovation to help our clients build a better financial future.
  • Insights
    • Back to Main Menu
    • See all Insights
      • Webinars
      • Podcasts
      • Research and Publications
      • Blogs
      • Case studies
      • Press Releases
      • Events
    • Webinars
      Register for upcoming webinars as well as visiting our extensive webinar replay library.
    • All Insights
      See our latest thinking.
  • Team
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Media Centre
  • Contact
  • The Brain
  • Search

Our website uses cookies (what’s this?). These cookies allow us to distinguish you from other users of our website, which helps us improve our website and to deliver many of the functions that make your browser experience more user-friendly. Some of the cookies that we use are essential for parts of the website to operate. By using this website you agree to our use of cookies. To find out more, including how to opt out, please read our Cookies Policy.

OK

Blog

Investment Pathways one year on – what do we know now?

28 Feb 2022

Jamie Freeman

by Jamie Freeman
Associate Consultant

Oscar Hussey

by Oscar Hussey
Associate Consultant

Subject: Digital and Innovation, Insurance & Reinsurance

Audiences: Insurance & Financial Services

One year on from the launch of Investment Pathways we are seeing a mixed bag of investment performance and customer engagement with the initiative across the industry. However, whilst Investment Pathways has been much maligned in some quarters, the concept is sound and it remains a welcome and important development for UK retirees going forward.

What is Investment Pathways?

Introduced in February 2021 by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), the Investment Pathways initiative requires pension providers to offer customers the choice of four investment solutions each designed to meet a high-level retirement objective over the next five years:

Without financial advice, consumers were often found to take the tax-free cash from their pot and leave the remainder sat in cash as a result of not making an active decision about it, missing out on the benefits of longer-term investing. The introduction of Investment Pathways allows these savers to identify their objectives with one of the four pathways and have access to an investment solution designed to meet that objective.

Despite this wide appeal, Investment Pathways is clearly not for everyone. Engaged investors or those with large pots for whom advice is more easily accessible and affordable are unlikely to find them useful. This is highlighted in the reported usage across the provider market, with different providers reporting a range from just 0.6% of savers engaging with Investment Pathways to over 90% engaging.

Some providers may be experiencing low usage because they typically attract more engaged investors or those with larger pots and thus more likely to take financial advice. We would not expect these providers to have a high level of Pathways usage. However, others may find this low usage is due to ineffective communications and signposting about Investment Pathways.

Communications, tooling and engagement

Across the industry we see very different approaches to developing communications and increasing customer engagement with the initiative. Many firms are offering basic, generic communications making it harder for customers to understand the Pathways and engage.

More progressive firms are providing personalised communication and tools for their customers which build on the Pathways retirement objectives, and communicate potential outcomes for the customer. In the case of the drawdown pathway, where the customer has control over their rate of withdrawal, these tools are vital to allow customers to understand how much money they can take out and for how long. By clearly integrating tools into the decision-making journey, these providers are enabling customers to better understand their retirement options and to develop a personalised retirement plan. Providers can differentiate themselves with strong communications and accessible personalised tooling for Investment Pathways. This will help to attract more customers and ensure that those who would use Pathways will maximise their benefits from it.

Investment allocations

Reviewing the market shows a wide variety of investment solutions proposed by different providers for each pathway. For example, for the full withdrawal pathway (Pathway 4), one firm has proposed an investment solution invested 25% in equities and more than 60% in bonds, whereas another has proposed an allocation almost entirely to cash. Firms have generally done a good job of making the investment risks known to their customers. However, with such a wide variation in asset allocation for a single five-year retirement objective, even before considering the impact of fund selection, we will see significantly divergent performance over time. There will be no hiding place for the providers who lag the performance table.   

Looking towards the future

There is an added complication for savers. Trust-based providers are not yet required to offer retirement solutions based on Investment Pathways. Someone reaching retirement with a personal pension and a trust based pension will find a confusing lack of consistency over the way their retirement options are presented to them. This must be addressed in order to help savers at retirement.

Whilst Investment Pathways has its issues, they are solvable. We hope that firms continue to develop their Investment Pathways solutions through clearer signposting; well-considered asset allocations; and much more personalised digital engagement tooling for customers. The more we can inform and guide those entering retirement, the better the expected investment outcomes for unadvised customers.

Subscribe to our news and insights

Related content

Richard Stock appointed Head of Property and Casualty

News 16 Jun 2022

Cognitive bias as a barrier to tackling climate change

Blogs 16 Jun 2022

Climate Biennial Exploratory Scenario: What’s next for insurers?

Publications 01 Jun 2022

Key investment themes 2022 for DC schemes, insurers and retail investors

Podcasts 19 May 2022

0 comments on this post

Comment

  • Share this via Twitter
  • Share this via Linkedin
  • Share this via Email
Related content
Close related articles

Richard Stock appointed Head of Property and Casualty

News

Cognitive bias as a barrier to tackling climate change

Blogs

Climate Biennial Exploratory Scenario: What’s next for insurers?

Publications

Key investment themes 2022 for DC schemes, insurers and retail investors

Podcasts

Subscribe to our news and insights

Menu

About

    • Abelica Global
    • About us
    • Award-winning advice
    • Careers
    • CSR
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Our Centenary

Legal

  • Accessibility
  • Modern Slavery Act Transparency Statement
  • Trust centre
  • Privacy notice
  • Terms of use

Resources

  • Conflicts of Interest
  • Coronavirus (COVID-19)
  • Responsible Investment
  • Gender Pay Gap
  • Sitemap

Contact

  • Our offices
  • Get in touch
  • Subscribe
    • Visit us on Linkedin
    • Visit us on Twitter
    • Visit us on Instagram
    • Visit us on Vimeo
    • Visit us on Spreaker
Hymans Robertson

Copyright © 2022 Hymans Robertson LLP. All rights reserved.