• Jump to main content
  • Jump to main navigation
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Media Centre
  • Contact
  • The Brain
Hymans Robertson
  • Pensions
    • Back to Main Menu
    • Defined Benefit Consulting
      • DB Actuarial
      • DB Investment
      • DB Pensions Administration
      • DB Risk Transfer
      • DB Member Choice – At retirement
      • DB Governance
      • DB Consolidation
      • DB Wind-up
      • Project Planning and Management
      • Fiduciary Oversight
      • Responsible Investment
    • Defined Contribution Consulting
      • DC Pension Strategy
      • DC Scheme Structure
      • DC Investment
      • DC Engagement
      • DC Member Choice - At-retirement
      • DC Governance
      • Guided Outcomes
      • DC Master Trusts
      • Benefits and Rewards Strategy
      • Project Planning and Management
      • Responsible Investment
      • Communications
    • Public Sector Consulting
      • LGPS Actuarial
      • LGPS Investment
      • LGPS Governance, Administration and Projects
      • LGPS Employers
      • Ill Health Liability Insurance
      • Responsible Investment
  • Financial Services
    • Back to Main Menu
    • Insurance
      • Longevity Management
      • Product Development
      • Risk and Capital Management
      • Investment and ALM
      • Insurance Company Regulation
      • Independent Actuarial Review Services
      • Project Planning and Management
    • Retail Advisory
      • Tailored Portfolio Service
    • Pension Providers
      • Digital Tools and APIs
      • Competitive Benchmarking
      • Proposition development
      • Operational Support
    • Digital Tools and APIs
      • GO™ For Investment Pathways
      • Economic Scenario Service
      • API Catalogue
  • Digital & Innovation
    • Back to Main Menu
    • Digital & Innovation
      • API Catalogue
      • Economic Scenario Service
      • Digital Products
    • Economic Scenario Service
      Explore the consequences of today's business decisions
    • Digital and Innovation
      Helping our clients build better financial futures
  • Insights
    • Back to Main Menu
    • See all Insights
      • Blogs
      • Case studies
      • Events
      • Podcasts
      • Research and Publications
      • Webinars
    • Webinars
      Watch our webinars
    • All Insights
      See all our latest Insights
  • Team
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Media Centre
  • Contact
  • The Brain
  • Search

Our website uses cookies (what’s this?). These cookies allow us to distinguish you from other users of our website, which helps us improve our website and to deliver many of the functions that make your browser experience more user-friendly. Some of the cookies that we use are essential for parts of the website to operate. By using this website you agree to our use of cookies. To find out more, including how to opt out, please read our Cookies Policy.

OK

Blog

Are you wind-up ready?

19 Jul 2019

Christine  Cumming

by Christine Cumming
Head of Scheme Wind Ups

Subject: Defined benefit pensions

Audiences: Employers, Trustees

As we start to see pension schemes increasingly approach full buy-out funding, we surveyed 100 pension scheme trustees to assess their state of readiness to complete a wind-up. Of those surveyed, 63 said they feel confident and 30 said they are not concerned about the practical steps required to wind-up their scheme (when they can afford to do so). But is this confidence misplaced?  

While a wind-up is conceptually simple, it is often the most complex and costly project that a scheme will ever undertake. So let’s look into some of the detail to test whether you are indeed wind-up ready.

Data cleansing – is your membership data buy-out ready?

Trustees often think their data is in good shape without appreciating that significantly more data cleansing will be needed before wind-up. This is the last opportunity for trustees to ensure that every member gets the correct benefits at the right time. Carrying out a data audit at least 5 years from wind-up is a good way to avoid unexpected delays and unplanned costs. There will inevitably be unknowns and it is best to flush these out early in the process.

Benefits– have your legal advisers reviewed a detailed benefit specification?

This benefit specification will replace the Scheme’s Rules after wind-up so it must be right. For long established schemes with legacy benefit structures, this can be an extremely complex task. You’ll also need to check that the benefits held on members’ records are consistent with the specification. This process can sometimes flush out issues, so again it is worth making an early start.

Assets – do you hold any illiquid assets? 

If so, do you have a plan to exit these investments? Illiquid assets can be a valuable part of an overall investment strategy, however, at some point these assets will need to be cashed in - even if this is to sell the asset for a nominal sum. Even a £100 investment in an illiquid investment can hold up the wind-up of a scheme. 

Member communications – do you have a strategy of how you’ll engage with members?  

A wind-up can be a stressful time for members and particularly for pensioners who are relying on their monthly pension income. Unsettled members can quickly add time and cost to a wind-up. And any formal complaints can add months of delay to the process. Having a clear communications strategy and providing members with effective communications over the course of the scheme’s journey can help minimise this. 

Closing the gap - are you targeting a shortfall or surplus on wind-up?

Understanding what you are targeting, who is entitled to any surplus and how/when it is paid out is very important. Accurate monitoring is equally important in order to know when wind-up is affordable.

Historic annuities – do you have any and do you hold the relevant documentation?

While these annuities are often small in the context of the overall scheme, they can be difficult to sort out; documentation is often missing or incomplete, especially if different annuity providers have been used over the years. Reviewing policies early in the process is crucial to a smooth wind-up.

Project plans – do you have a wind-up plan in place?

If you’re still several years from winding-up, this could be very high level but it is important to start mapping out your scheme’s journey, and ultimately this will be key in helping control risk, costs and timescales when you reach wind-up.

Still confident? 

We hope so. But if not, with the right amount of planning a wind-up need not be a scary prospect. Broken down into bite sized chunks, and starting early enough, it should be possible to work your way through a wind-up without any sleepless nights. If you’d like to talk more about getting your scheme wind-up ready please get in touch.

Join our mailing list

Subscribe to our news and insights

Related content

What’s your pension goal?

Blogs 09 Feb 2017

A guide to the new DB funding code

Publications 04 Jul 2019

Member engagement for DB schemes

Publications 23 Jan 2019

Maximising Value in DB

Research 13 Sep 2018

0 comments on this post

Comment

  • Share this via Twitter
  • Share this via Linkedin
  • Share this via Email
Related content
Close related articles

What’s your pension goal?

Blogs

A guide to the new DB funding code

Publications

Member engagement for DB schemes

Publications

Maximising Value in DB

Research

Subscribe to our news and insights

Menu

About

    • About us
    • Careers
    • CSR
    • Award-winning advice
    • Abelica Global
    • Diversity & Inclusion

Legal

  • Accessibility
  • Modern Slavery Act Transparency Statement
  • Trust centre
  • Privacy notice
  • Terms of use

Resources

  • Brexit
  • Conflicts of Interest
  • Coronavirus (COVID-19)
  • Responsible Investment
  • Gender Pay Gap
  • Sitemap

Contact

  • Our offices
  • Get in touch
    • Visit us on Vimeo
    • Visit us on Linkedin
    • Visit us on Twitter
Hymans Robertson

Copyright © 2021 Hymans Robertson LLP. All rights reserved.